A brownie is best the day it leaves the oven. The top is still crisp at the edges of the crackle, and the centre is soft without being wet. That is the bite we bake for. If you can, open the box the day you collect it.
Keep every brownie in the fridge, covered, for up to 3 days. That is the same rule for the whole box: Classic Sea Salt, Golden Toffee Bliss, Berry Bliss, Tiramisu Cloud, and the quartet. A closed tin or the box they arrived in is enough. After the third day, they are past their best.
Take a piece out a little before you eat it. A cold brownie is firm. A few minutes on the counter lets the centre soften again without losing the crackle.
Warm it only if you want a softer centre. A few seconds is enough. Too long and the top steams, and the crackle you waited for goes soft. Then it is still chocolate. It is just no longer the brownie we packed.